All Comparisons
    Mattress Comparison
    Amerisleep AS4 mattress

    Amerisleep AS4

    VS
    Puffy Lux Hybrid mattress

    Puffy Lux Hybrid

    Amerisleep AS4 vs. Puffy Lux Hybrid

    Side-by-side comparison of the Amerisleep AS4 (Hybrid) and Puffy Lux Hybrid (Hybrid). Compare comfort, cooling, support, value and more — based on our lab testing.

    Winner: Amerisleep

    By Sleep Sage Editorial Team

    Side-by-side mattress testing · 144+ comparisons published

    Updated May 2026
    Category
    Amerisleep AS4
    Puffy Lux Hybrid
    Comfort
    9.5/10
    9.2/10
    Support
    8.5/10
    8.6/10
    Cooling
    8.8/10
    8.5/10
    Edge Support
    8.2/10
    8.3/10
    Motion Isolation
    9.2/10
    9/10
    Durability
    8.8/10
    8.7/10
    Value
    8.7/10
    8.4/10

    Quick Specs Comparison

    Spec
    Amerisleep AS4
    Puffy Lux Hybrid
    Price (Queen)
    $1,499
    $1,549
    Type
    Hybrid
    Hybrid
    Firmness
    4/10
    5/10
    Height
    12"
    12 inches
    Trial
    100 nights
    365 nights
    Warranty
    20 years
    Lifetime
    Shipping
    Free shipping
    Free shipping & returns

    Key Advantages

    Why Choose Amerisleep AS4

    • Outstanding pressure relief for side sleepers
    • Deep contouring at shoulders and hips eliminates pressure points
    • Excellent motion isolation — ideal for couples

    Why Choose Puffy Lux Hybrid

    • Outstanding pressure relief for side sleepers
    • 365-night trial with free shipping and free returns
    • Lifetime warranty, one of the few in the category

    Still Not Sure Which to Choose?

    Take our personalized sleep quiz to get matched with the ideal mattress for your needs.

    Take the Sleep QuizView All Comparisons

    More Resources

    Brands behind these picks

    Before you buy, read the brand: construction, pricing bands, trial and warranty terms, and how each company's lineup performed in our Encinitas lab.

    Browse every mattress brand we cover

    Continue exploring

    Hand-picked guides and reviews from our editorial team.